No Job Description? No Go for Recruiting

by Stephen Bruce | BLR


In legally dangerous territory of recruiting, there are a lot of potential mistakes. But the biggest mistake is setting out without a clear picture of what you are looking for.


Good Applicants Steer Clear

First of all, think from the point of view of the applicants. They are trying to  figure out what you are looking for and if it’s a good fit for them. If your  description of the position is vague, two things happen:


  1. The really good candidates steer clear—they can tell you don’t have it together, and they pass on by. 
  2. Unqualified candidates will line up in droves—with a vague description, almost all candidates can convince themselves that they are qualified.

You’ve lost the game even before you start: Your pool of candidates doesn’t even  include the best prospects, and it’s full of unqualified people that you’ll  have to wade through.


Evaluations Are Meaningless

Then you start the evaluation process, comparing candidates to pick those to move  along in the recruiting process. 


But with no clear picture of what you need, you’re really just guessing. Your evaluations are essentially meaningless. But, OK, eventually you get a list of  finalists to interview. 


Unfortunately,  when you don’t know what you are looking for, your interview will devolve into  chitchat, small talk, and general beating-about-the-bush. You’ll make some  decisions about candidates, but based on what? Probably personality and  likeability. (Were those the discrimination bells ringing?)


Eventually, you’ll make a job offer. What’s the likelihood that you’ll end up with a  well-qualified hire? Not high.


Bottom Line—Start with a Job Description

Let’s  go back to those applicants. If you’ve used a well-written job description to  prepare recruiting materials—that is, the information you post or print or  share with recruiters to advertise the job—applicants can make a meaningful  self-screening. 


The  better candidates will eagerly apply when they see a believable job description  that matches their expertise and desires.


Will  unqualified candidates still apply? Sure, but most will screen themselves out,  and the ones that do apply won’t be angry or surprised when they don’t advance  to the next round—they’ll know it was a long shot.


Then comes the selection of candidates to interview. From the job description you  prepare a clear list of the skills, abilities, and attributes you need. It’s easy to screen candidates against that.


Is it time to interview? Actually, before you interview, ask yourself, is an  interview the best way to find out what we need to know about these candidates? 

Read 2526 times Last modified on Tuesday, 22 July 2014 09:39


Key Trends in Recruiting to Identify, Engage, and Hire Top Talent

Here are some of the top trends in recruiting that promise to change the way organizations identify, engage, and ultimately hire top talent in the coming years and how employers can adapt procedures to these changes to ensure a successful recruiting program.

Preemployment inquiries under the FMLA and ADA: What's prohibited?

This article examines similarities and differences between the FMLA and the ADA so that you can stay in compliance when both laws apply.

Look Behind the Credentials: Find Candidates with Multiple Skillsets

The first instinct of any recruiter or HR professional is to look at the title. This can be a grave misstep because titles are often misleading.